| Extra Point Attempts | Game | 6 | Mike Kincaid vs. Churchville-Chili John D'Alonzo vs. Greece Olympia Sean Simpson vs. Churchville-Chili Brian Hugelmaier vs. Penfield |
2008 2007 2002 2001 |
Season | 32 | Brian Hugelmaier | 2001 | Career | 32 | Brian Hugelmaier | 1999-2001 |
| Extra Point Conversions | Game | 6 | Mike Kincaid vs. Churchville-Chili | 2008 | Season | 21 | Brian Hugelmaier | 2001 | Career | 28 | Kyle Muir | 2003-2005 |
| Field Goal Attempts | Game | 3 | Kyle Muir vs. Franklin Al Kordovski vs. Penfield |
2005 1999 |
Season | 9 | Kyle Muir | 2005 | Career | 11 | Kyle Muir | 2003-2005 |
| Field Goal Conversions | Game | 2 | Sean Simpson vs. Greece Arcadia | 2002 | Season | 5 | Kyle Muir | 2005 | Career | 10 | Kyle Muir | 2003-2005 |
| Punting Attempts | Game | 8 | Rob Dermody vs. Greece Arcadia & Greece Athena | 1999 | Season | 48 | Rob Dermody | 1999 | Career | 107 | Kyle Muir | 2003-2005 |